
Lesson Plans -- Student
The Civil Rights Movement
A Document Based Question
by Rebecca Taylor
Directions: Read all of the primary documents provided to you in Part A. Using complete sentences, answer the questions that follow the documents. Use the documents and your prior knowledge to complete the essay in Part B.
Historical Context: Throughout the twentieth century, African Americans fought for equal status in many different facets of life. This movement, known as the Civil Rights Movement, intensified in the 1960s as a number of advocates (Martin Luther King, etc) began to demand equality.
Task: Use information provided in the primary documents in Part A to complete the essay in Part B. Your essay should follow a logical order and answer the following questions:
- Name FOUR changes African Americans wanted made in their rights as citizens.
- Explain how African Americans were instrumental in changing their own situation. Describe THREE methods of protest.
- Based on your knowledge and reading of the documents, do you believe that African Americans have succeeded in their goals? Support your answer.
Part A: Documents and Short-Answer Questions
Document 1 Photographs, "Drinking Fountains in the Dougherty County Courthouse," 1963 and "Greensboro Lunch Counter Sit In," 1960.
Question 1: What does the top photograph demonstrate? What does the fact that the drinking fountains are in a courthouse tell you about the obstacles African Americans will have to overcome?
Question 2: The bottom photograph shows African Americans in a "Whites Only" lunch counter in Greensboro, North Carolina. Why do you think they are there and why is this important to the Civil Rights Movement?
Document 2 Excerpt, "A Million New Negro Voters?" U. S. News and World Report, August 16, 1965
President Johnson signed the voting-rights bill for Negroes on Friday, August 6, and immediately set the vast machinery of the U. S. Government into motion to enforce the law.
On Saturday, August 7, the U. S. Department of Justice certified the States where racial discrimination in voting is officially declared to exist.
Justice Department officials worked through the week-end, choosing the key 'hard-core' counties and rushing federal examiners into those counties to start registering Negro voters on Tuesday, August 10.
Question 3: What rights does President Johnson's bill provide to African Americans?
Document 3 Excerpt, Brown V. Board of Education, 1954
Segregation of white and Negro children in public schools of a State solely on the basis of race, pursuant to state laws permitting or requiring such segregation, denies to Negro children the equal protection of the laws guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment-even though the physical facilities and other 'tangible' factors of white and Negro schools may be equal...
Where a State has undertaken to provide an opportunity for an education in its public schools, such an opportunity is a right which must be made available to all on equal terms.
Question 4: According to this document, how did the school system define "equality" before this ruling? What right is being guaranteed to African Americans by this ruling?
Document 4 Excerpt, "Letter from a Birmingham Jail," Martin Luther King, Jr., April 16, 1963.
There can be no gainsaying the fact that racial injustice engulfs this community. Birmingham is probably the most thoroughly segregated city in the United States. Its ugly record of brutality is widely known. Negroes have experienced grossly unjust treatment in the courts. There have been more unsolved bombings of Negro homes and churches in Birmingham than in any other city in the nation. These are the hard, brutal facts of the case. On the basis of these conditions, Negro leaders sought to negotiate with the city fathers. But the latter consistently refused to engage in good-faith negotiation.
Then, last September, came the opportunity to talk with leaders of Birmingham's economic community. In the course of the negotiations, certain promises were made by the merchants --- for example, to remove the stores humiliating racial signs. On the basis of these promises, the Reverend Fred Shuttlesworth and the leaders of the Alabama Christian Movement for Human Rights agreed to a moratorium on all demonstrations. As the weeks and months went by, we realized that we were the victims of a broken promise. A few signs, briefly removed, returned; the others remained.
You may well ask: "Why direct action? Why sit-ins, marches and so forth? Isn't negotiation a better path?" You are quite right in calling, for negotiation. Indeed, this is the very purpose of direct action. Nonviolent direct action seeks to create such a crisis and foster such a tension that a community which has constantly refused to negotiate is forced to confront the issue. It seeks so to dramatize the issue that it can no longer be ignored. My citing the creation of tension as part of the work of the nonviolent-resister may sound rather shocking. But I must confess that I am not afraid of the word "tension." I have earnestly opposed violent tension, but there is a type of constructive, nonviolent tension which is necessary for growth.
Question 5: Why are the African Americans of Birmingham protesting?
Question 6: What methods of protest are African Americans using? Define these methods.
Document 5 Excerpt from "Negroes' Most Urgent Needs," presented to the Montgomery, Alabama City Council by African American residents, c. 1954-55.
3. Subdivision for housing
Just recently a project for a sub-division for Negroes was presented before the City Commission for approval. Protests from whites and other objections prevented the development. There is no section wherein Negroes can expand to build decent homes. What of Lincoln heights?
4. Jobs for qualified Negroes.
Certain civil service jobs are not open to Negroes, yet many are qualified. Negroes need jobs commensurate [equal] with their training. Everybody cannot teach.
What are African Americans in Montgomery lacking that they feel they should be entitled to?
Document 6 "Bus Boycott Conference Fails to Find Solution," Montgomery Advertiser, December 9, 1955
Montgomery Negroes will continue to boycott city busses until a "satisfactory" seating arrangement is devised, a spokesman told officials of City Bus Lines yesterday.
The Rev. M. L. King, speaking for a delegation that conferred with bus lines officials for four hours, proposed that bus patrons be seated on a "first come, first served" basis with no sections reserved for either race.
Negroes would continue to seat from the rear and whites from the front, he said, but there would be no reassignment of seats once the busses were loaded.
He laid down two other conditions sought by Negroes: More courteous treatment and the hiring of Negro drivers on routes "predominantly" Negro.
Question 8: What methods are African Americans of Montgomery using to voice their concerns as described in this article? Are those methods consistent with the theory of nonviolence as described by Martin Luther King, Jr. in Document 4?
Document 7 Photographs, March on Washington, August 28, 1963
Question 9: From the photographs, what do you believe was the aim of the march?
Document 8 Excerpt, Interview with Wazir (Willie B.) Peacock, Civil Rights Movement Veteran, July 2001
At that time, we used the media. The media was showing to the country what was going on, and by the same token, they had to explain why we were out there demonstrating. At the time, some people who thought we shouldn't be doing that, like "How dare you?" Especially in the South, they weren't ready to see what we were doing, so it sure made them angry. It brought about a lot of Klan activity. Sure that hurt, but it was a part of the whole thing that was necessary. We couldn't avoid that. Those people had been oppressed by these forces all the time. It was a time for confrontation, to bring it all out to the surface, so in that sense, the sit-ins, the marches, and all of that was necessary, and it helped.
Question 10: In this excerpt, Mr. Peacock explains that civil rights activists used the media to their advantage. What reason does he give for this strategy?
Grading and Answer Key
Question 1 (5 points)
The word I am looking for here is "segregation." If the students do not use this particular term, they may still receive partial credit by explaining that it shows the separation of whites and African Americans in public spaces. As for the second part of the question, I would expect the students to conclude that the discrimination was beyond ordinary citizens; that it was, in fact, ingrained in the laws of the U. S.
Question 2 (5 points)
Students may not be aware of the term "sit-in" (hopefully they would after we finished the unit), but I would expect them to state that the African Americans in the photograph are protesting the fact that the diner is for whites only. As far as its importance, I would accept any reasonable answer, but I would hope that they would understand that this shows the willingness of African Americans to fight on their own behalf.
Question 3 (5 points)
To receive full credit for this question, students need to state that the bill allowed African Americans to vote without discrimination. I would expect them to remember some of the specific discriminatory tools (i.e., tests) from the unit and in asking them to make their answer specific, I am asking them to draw on prior knowledge as much as they can.
Question 4 (5 points)
I would expect students to answer that African Americans lacked the right to attend schools where they were provided with an education equal to that of white children and that, prior to the ruling, schools had determined "equal" to mean buildings that were physically the same. In this ruling, they were given the right to receive the same quality of education as white children.
Question 5 (5 points)
In the excerpt from the letter, many reasons for protest are listed (segregation, brutality, discrimination in court, bombings, racist signs, etc). I would expect the students to list at least three of them for full credit.
Question 6 (5 points)
Dr. King mentions that African Americans are using "nonviolent direct action," which he defines as creating a tension that cannot be ignored. He also mentions sit-ins and marches. I would expect students to know these terms and define at least two of them for full credit.
Question 7 (5 points)
In answer to this question, students should name the two complaints, which are that African Americans have no place to build good homes and that African Americans are not able to apply for jobs that they have been trained for. Both need to be included in the answer for full credit.
Question 8 (5 points)
Students should answer that the African Americans in the article are using a boycott as a method of protest. They should also conclude that this method was in accordance with the theory of nonviolence.
Question 9 (5 points)
There are many possible answers for this question, but only one will receive full credit. For example, the signs in the photographs show numerous complaints, such as lack of proper jobs and wages, lack of "decent housing," etc., but the answer I am looking for is that the aim of the March on Washington was to be heard by the nation's leaders. The students should conclude as much from the location of the march and the photograph of the leaders with President Kennedy.
Question 10 (5 points)
I would expect the students to understand from the passage that the civil rights activists used the media because it was the media's job to not only report the events, but also to explain why those events were happening. Students should note that in this way, African Americans were voicing their opinions to the nation.
Essay (50 points)
In their response to the essay question, I would expect students to include the following for full credit:
- Any for of the rights African Americans demanded.
- These could include equal voting rights, equal housing, equal education, desegregation, an end to violence and racism, equal rights in court, better jobs and equal pay, or recognition by the nation's leaders as equal citizens.
- Any three ways African Americans attempted to change their status.
- These could include sit-ins, marches, media coverage, boycotts, attempts at communication with government leaders, or nonviolent action. I would also expect students to thoroughly describe the action (i.e., what it entailed.)
- Their opinion as to whether or not African Americans succeeded.
- Due to the fact that this is an opinion question, the only requirement I would have is that the students support their claims. They should use at least two pieces of evidence, meaning facts that support their conclusion.
Explanation of Documents
Document 1
This document consists of two photographs, one depicting "white" and "colored" drinking fountains and the other a sit-in at a diner. I chose these two photographs to show the realities of segregation and the bravery of those who struggled against it. My hope would be that the students would put together that African Americans fought segregation by mostly peaceful desegregation of public places.
Photograph one: American Treasures of the Library of Congress.
http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/odyssey/archive/09/0909001r.jpg
Photograph two: Library of Congress.
http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/treasures/images/vc84.jpg
Document 2
Document two is an excerpt from an article in U. S. News and World Report describing President Johnson signing a bill to make voting fair and equal by eliminating discrimination (tests, etc.). I want the students to see the presence of racial injustice in many different areas of African American life, not just the famous boycotts and such, though they were important as well. I want the students to understand why African Americans wanted the right to vote on equal footing with whites.
Library of Congress, General Collections.
http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/odyssey/archive/09/0920001r.jpg
Document 3
This document shows the student not only what the ruling was in the Brown v. Board of Education case, but it also shows what right African Americans had been lacking up to the date of the decision. I excerpted this, and I chose the sections I did because they are fairly easy to read and the students could use context clues to figure out the meanings of words they do not know.
Our Documents.gov.
http://www.ourdocuments.gov/doc.php?doc=87&page=transcript
Document 4
I chose these excerpts from the letter because I thought it important that students realize the reasoning behind the actions of the civil rights activists. I thought that this piece successfully conveys not only the reasons for employing certain methods, but also it explains why nonviolent action was effective. There was one word that I had to define as it was crucial to the point being made and I was not sure that high school students would have heard it before.
The Martin Luther King, Jr. Papers at Stanford University.
http://liberationcommunity.stanford.edu/TopicPages/letter_birmingham.html
Document 5
I found this document on a web site for teachers. It was part of a lesson plan on the movement. I used it because it explains needs of African Americans that are not usually addressed in the civil rights curriculum. I thought it would give the students a better understanding of the fact that there were reasons other than segregation for the civil rights protests.
Alabama Department of Archives and History
http://archives.state.al.us/teacher/rights/lesson1/doc4.html
Document 6
Again, this was from a web site for teachers. I chose it because it shows clearly the requests of African Americans and their willingness to cooperate with officials, which was in accordance with Dr. King's theory of nonviolence. It also mentions boycotting, which could be used by the students in their essay.
Alabama Department of Archives and History
http://archives.state.al.us/teacher/rights/lesson1/doc3.html
Document 7
I used these photographs because they are extremely powerful and I think the students will respond well to them. Both the photograph of the march leaders with President Kennedy and the shots of protesters clearly convey the wish of African Americans that the leaders of the nation hear their demands. I am hoping that these photographs evoke emotion from the students.
Photograph one and two: The Civil Rights Movement
http://abbeville.com/civilrights/washington.asp
Photograph three: About.com.
http://afroamhistory.about.com/library/blphotos_march_leaders_marching1.htm
Document 8
This document was very interesting to me because it is a recent interview with a civil rights veteran. I think it provides an interesting view of the decision to used the media to the advantage of the activists, and it adds a different perspective to the collection of documents, as it has the distance of time.
Civil Rights Movement Veterans.
http://www.crmvet.org/